THE MAGIC BOX by Rob Young (Faber & Faber, 2021)
Rob Young was brilliant at uncovering Britain’s visionary music in ‘Electric Eden’, a definitive study of folk music in the UK that took the reader/listener far away from the mainstream. He is less successful in attempting to apply similar insights into the nation’s visual memory bank.
A more academic approach to television history would have reflected upon innovative works of writers and directors such as Allan Clarke, Alan Bennett, Dennis Potter, David Leland, Ken Loach and Mike Leigh. Rob Young charts a less linear and more idiosyncratic course . The original works of Nigel Kneale are rightly feted but that doesn’t mean these more established names should have been excluded.
Surprisingly, there is also no mention of many of the many cult TV series I remember from the 1960s and 1970s like The Prisoner , The Champions , Adam Adamant Lives!, Doomwatch , Gangsters and Jason King . Nor does Young mention any of the long running soap operas and largely ignores comedy shows.
I understand that any study of the period must be subjective but it seems to me that Young’s viewpoint on British culture implies that ghost stories and folk horror were the dominant genres. The political background is for the most part peripheral as the emphasis is on his own memories and the idiosyncrasies of the British character.
TV output from the 1950s to the present provides such a rich source of material that it’s a pity Young chose also to spread his net even wider to include cult movies. In my view, he should have stuck to the small screen. A cinematic history of Britain belongs to a separate study.
At his best, Young shows that the weirdness that influenced the alternative music scene was matched by eccentric TV programming of the era . This transported unsuspecting viewers into strange and, often, scary territories. Many of the shows referred to were one-offs that have only recently resurfaced in all their ghostly glory on You Tube and other online sites.
This book is valuable for shedding light on these obscure dramas and documentaries but too many of these half-forgotten titles are merely listed and described rather than contextualised. The best section is entitled Divided Kingdom because he covers race, class and gender. These issues are essential to any deeper understanding of British multi-faceted cultural history.